Parcel · 08-26-19-0020-00000-0920
5213 EAGLE ISLAND DRIVE, LAND O LAKES 34639
From the Property Appraiser's bulk roll · Sun, Aug 9, 2026
Owned byBOTTERMAN WILLIAM & SARAH
Part of LAKE PADGETT PINES — UNIT 1 · plat book 14/20
Valuation
- Just value
- $420,261
- County assessed
- $382,370
- County taxable
- $330,959
- Acres
- 0.75 ac
- Use code
- 00100
Structure
- Single Family Residentialbuilt 1991Excellent quality
- Heated sqft
- 2,334
- Total sqft
- 3,010
- Bathrooms
- 2
- Stories
- 2
- Value
- $319,278
Average · Asphalt or Composition Shingle · Central
Land (3 tiers)
| Use | Zoning | Units | Assessed |
|---|---|---|---|
| SFR Waterfront | 0PUD | 10,000 Square Feet | $52,300 |
| SFR Waterfront | 0PUD | 5,000 Square Feet | $26,150 |
| SFR Waterfront | 0PUD | 17,832 Square Feet | $6,598 |
Floor breakdown
- FINISHED UPPER STORY1,312 sf
- LIVING AREA1,022 sf
- FINISHED GARAGE420 sf
- FINISHED OPEN PORCH256 sf
Extra features (10)
- DRVWAY/SIDEWALK CONC (1991)$1,088
- FIREPLACE (1991)$950
- JACUZZI (1996)$750
- POOL 6 FOOT DEPTH (1996)$6,696
- COOL DECK (1996)$924
- SCREENED ENCL A FRM (1996)$2,280
- SIDEWALK CONCRETE (1996)$227
- SUNDECK (2000)$909
- SHED (2006)$210
- PVC FENCING (SF) (2024)$1,901
Owner
- BOTTERMAN WILLIAM & SARAH5213 EAGLE ISLAND DRIVE, LAND O LAKES FL 34639
Sale history (7)
| Date | Price | Deed | Qual |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2024-02-26 | $495,000 | WD | 01 |
| 2021-04-28 | $420,000 | WD | 01 |
| 2015-02-11 | $80,000 | WD | 38 |
| 1986-11-01 | $8,800 | FS | Q |
| 1983-05-01 | — | WD | Q |
| 1980-04-01 | — | — | Q |
| 1978-11-01 | — | — | Q |
Year-by-year history2019–2025
| Year | Owner | Just value | Taxable |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | BOTTERMAN WILLIAM & SARAH | $434,459 | $321,597 |
| 2024 | BOTTERMAN WILLIAM & SARAH | $417,374 | $330,140 |
| 2023 | HORNING JOSEPH TYNDALE & ASHLE | $419,482 | $319,070 |
| 2022 | HORNING JOSEPH TYNDALE & ASHLE | $358,322 | $308,322 |
| 2021 | HORNING JOSEPH TYNDALE & ASHLE | $271,005 | $149,850 |
| 2020 | CASSEL KENNETH & LINDA | $261,934 | $147,100 |
| 2019 | CASSEL KENNETH & LINDA | $249,711 | $142,670 |
Rows tinted brick indicate the owner changed from the prior year. Source: FL DOR annual NAL files via the PA historic archive.
Legal description
LAKE PADGETT PINES UNIT 1 PB 14 PGS 20-26 LOT 92