Parcel · 13-25-16-0070-00000-1320
9540 STAR TRAIL, NEW PORT RICHEY 34654
From the Property Appraiser's bulk roll · Fri, Nov 6, 2026
Owned byMOTTELER GARY K & KAREN
Part of OSCEOLA HEIGHTS — UNIT SIX · plat book 7/99
Valuation
- Just value
- $557,193
- County assessed
- $392,710
- County taxable
- $0
- Acres
- 1 ac
- Use code
- 00100
Structures (2)
- Single Family Residentialbuilt 1982Excellent quality
- Heated sqft
- 3,416
- Total sqft
- 4,728
- Bathrooms
- 3
- Stories
- 2
- Value
- $452,513
Average · Asphalt or Composition Shingle · Central
- Metal Bldg Miscbuilt 2015Below Average quality
- Heated sqft
- 900
- Stories
- 1
- Value
- $17,053
Modular Metal · Min Roof(Corr. or Sh M) · None
Land
| Use | Zoning | Units | Assessed |
|---|---|---|---|
| SFR | 00ER | 43,564.92 Square Feet | $69,704 |
Floor breakdown
- LIVING AREA2,384 sf
- FINISHED UPPER STORY1,032 sf
- FINISHED GARAGE600 sf
- LIVING AREA900 sf
- FINISHED OPEN PORCH504 sf
- FINISHED SCREENED ALUM PORCH208 sf
Extra features (8)
- DRVWAY/SIDEWALK CONC (1982)$1,089
- FIREPLACE (1982)$408
- POOL 6 FOOT DEPTH (1984)$8,370
- COOL DECK (1984)$1,465
- UTILITY SHED (2004)$120
- SCREENED ENCL A FRM (2013)$4,216
- DECORATIVE FENCE (2013)$323
- CHAIN LINK FENCE (2025)$1,932
Owner
- MOTTELER GARY K & KAREN9540 STAR TRL, NEW PORT RICHEY FL 34654-2540
Sale history (6)
| Date | Price | Deed | Qual |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2012-08-31 | $152,000 | WD | 01 |
| 2007-10-01 | — | WD | U |
| 2003-08-01 | — | WD | U |
| 2001-04-01 | — | WD | U |
| 1999-11-01 | — | WD | U |
| 1999-10-01 | $159,000 | WD | Q |
Year-by-year history2019–2025
| Year | Owner | Just value | Taxable |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | MOTTELER GARY K & KAREN | $565,767 | $0 |
| 2024 | MOTTELER GARY K & KAREN | $555,245 | $0 |
| 2023 | MOTTELER GARY K & KAREN | $582,380 | $0 |
| 2022 | MOTTELER GARY K & KAREN | $470,208 | $0 |
| 2021 | MOTTELER GARY K & KAREN | $373,068 | $0 |
| 2020 | MOTTELER GARY K & KAREN | $333,752 | $0 |
| 2019 | MOTTELER GARY K & KAREN | $327,846 | $0 |
Rows tinted brick indicate the owner changed from the prior year. Source: FL DOR annual NAL files via the PA historic archive.
Legal description
OSCEOLA HEIGHTS UNIT 6 PB 7 PG 99 POR TR 132 DESC AS COM SW COR TR 132 TH ALG WLY BDY LN TR 132 N06DEG36'57"W 914.41 FT TO NW COR TR 132 TH ALG NLY BDY LINE TR 132 30.00 FT ALG ARC CURVE TO LEFT FOR POB RAD 840.09 FT CHD 30.00 FT BRG N84DEG08'57"E TH CONT ALG NLY BDY LN TR 132 199.40 FT ALG ARC OF CURVE TO LEFT RAD 840.09 FT CHD 198.93 FT BRG N76DEG19'34"E TH S17DEG 04' 33"E 204.15 FT TH S76DEG19' 34"W 236.27 FT TH PARALLEL WITH WLY BDY LINE TR 132 N06DG 36'57"W 205.34 FT TO POB OR 8748 PG 3839